The case in opposition to Nickelback by Snowblind Revival songwriter Kirk Johnston over their 2006 hit “Rockstar” has been dismissed. In response to a report by Billboard, U.S. District Choose Robert Pitman has dominated that there are not any similarities between Nickelback‘s tune and Snowblind Revival‘s 2001 tune “Rock Star,” and that there isn’t any proof that Nickelback ever heard the tune.
“Said merely, they don’t sound alike,” wrote Pitman in his ruling. “The place each songs evoke comparable themes, they’re rendered dissimilar via the vivid element of the unique expression in Nickelback‘s lyrics.” Pitman later mentioned that the lawsuit “borders on the absurd” and that there is actually nothing in widespread between the 2 songs except for a couple of analogies and “outlandish stereotypes and pictures related to being an enormous, well-known, rock star.”
Within the authentic lawsuit, Johnston alleged Nickelback had entry to his demo, which was submitted to Roadrunner Data’ mum or dad corporations Common Music Group and Warner Music Group, and that Nickelback stole “a considerable quantity of the music in ‘Rockstar’.”
In a 2021 response, Nickelback mentioned the 2 songs sound nothing alike, and that “Johnston did not determine any particular lyrical similarities between the works at concern; he might solely conceivably level to the titles of the 2 works and ‘lyrical themes,'” that the 2 songs aren’t even written in the identical type, and that not one of the melodies match up.
Nickelback additionally referred to as Johnston out on offering no particulars about his conferences with report labels and the Snowblind Revival demo, including Johnston failed to present “the names of the report label representatives with whom he allegedly met, the place the conferences passed off, and even when the conferences passed off.”
And let’s be actual right here – these two songs don’t have anything in widespread in any respect except for that they are each named “Rockstar” and “Rock Star.” Positive they take care of the identical normal matter, however think about if lyrical ideas might solely be utilized by one artist. Rock music would’ve been out of enterprise many years in the past.
Need Extra Steel? Subscribe To Our Day by day E-newsletter
Enter your e-mail under to get a day by day replace with all of our headlines.